home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=89TT0059>
- <link 93TG0019>
- <title>
- Jan. 02, 1989: Hands Across The Sea
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1989
- Jan. 02, 1989 Planet Of The Year:Endangered Earth
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- PLANET OF THE YEAR, Page 54
- Hands Across the Sea
- </hdr><body>
- <p>Rich and poor, north and south, nations must get it together or
- face common disaster
- </p>
- <p>By Thomas A. Sancton
- </p>
- <p> It is easy to draw up a plan of action for protecting the
- earth. But that plan will fail unless it is forged with
- international fellowship and carried out on a global scale. How
- much good can one country do by reducing carbon-dioxide
- emissions if another nation offsets that with an increased
- output of CO2? How can one country keep its beaches clean if
- its neighbor down the coast dumps sewage or syringes into the
- sea? "On most environmental questions, the nation-state is
- obsolete," said Pace University's Nicholas Robinson. "We have
- to talk about multinational cooperation."
- </p>
- <p> The first goal of that cooperative effort should be to
- gather the information needed to fashion effective policies.
- "We've got to get the earth in intensive care, to start to
- monitor the vital signs of the planet," said John Eddy of the
- University Corporation for Atmospheric Research in Boulder.
- This could be done by launching an International Earthwatch
- Program, possibly under the aegis of the United Nations, to
- coordinate multinational research projects and centralize
- essential data on the state of the world. Such an umbrella
- program could pool the results of hundreds of existing research
- efforts. A prime candidate for this program would be the Mission
- to Planet Earth, recommended by former astronaut Sally Ride,
- which would use NASA facilities to study the earth from space.
- In addition to improving knowledge of the earth's ills, an
- International Earthwatch Program could provide the basis for a
- widespread awareness-building campaign aimed at preparing public
- opinion for the sacrifices and life-style changes that will be
- necessary in the coming decades. Environmental education
- programs should be immediately introduced into schools and
- workplaces around the world, and government leaders should bring
- these issues into the heart of political debate.
- </p>
- <p> But research and education are no substitutes for concrete
- action. The world community must move promptly toward
- comprehensive treaties to protect the air, soil and water. A
- framework for the effort exists within the U.N., which has
- already taken some important initiatives. In 1972 the U.N.
- organized the landmark Stockholm conference, which set up the
- United Nations Environment Program. It was under UNEP's
- sponsorship that 24 countries signed the 1987 Montreal
- Protocol, calling for a reduction in the output of
- ozone-destroying chlorofluorocarbons. There have also been
- proposals to enhance UNEP's role as a sort of intergovernmental
- superagency on environmental questions.
- </p>
- <p> Paralleling the U.N.'s efforts, multilateral financial
- institutions have a crucial role to play. The World Bank, which
- lends money for Third World development projects, was long
- criticized by environmental groups for backing large,
- ecologically unsound programs -- a cattle-raising scheme in
- Botswana that led to overgrazing, for example. During the past
- few years, however, the World Bank has been seeking to factor
- environmental concerns into its programs. One product of this
- new approach is an environmental action plan for Madagascar.
- The 20-year plan, which will be drawn up jointly with the World
- Wide Fund for Nature, aims at heightening public awareness of
- environmental issues, setting up and managing protected areas
- and encouraging sustainable development. Similar aims should
- also guide the lending policies of the International Monetary
- Fund, regional development banks and bilateral assistance
- programs.
- </p>
- <p> Much of the current environmental crisis is rooted in, and
- exacerbated by, the widening gap between rich and poor nations.
- Industrialized countries contain only 23% of the world's
- population, yet they control 80% of the world's goods and are
- also responsible for the bulk of its pollution. On the other
- hand, it is the developing countries that are hardest hit by
- overpopulation, malnutrition and disease. As these nations
- struggle to catch up with the developed world, a vicious circle
- begins: their efforts at rapid industrialization poison their
- cities, while their attempts to boost agricultural production
- often result in the destruction of their forests and the
- depletion of their soils.
- </p>
- <p> The greatest obstacle to economic and environmental
- improvements in the developing countries is their mammoth
- foreign debt. Collectively, the Third World owes $1.2 trillion
- to the banks and governments of industrialized countries. A new
- World Bank report estimates that in 1988 the developing
- countries made net payments of $43 billion to the industrial
- nations, up from $38 billion in 1987. How can the rich nations
- expect poor countries to launch environmental programs while
- struggling to pay off those crippling loans? Clearly, the Third
- World's debt payments will have to be lightened or postponed.
- The best way of doing that seems to be using debt forgiveness as
- leverage for winning environmental concessions.
- </p>
- <p> One approach that has already been pursued successfully on a
- small scale is the so-called debt-for-nature swaps. Conceived by
- the Smithsonian Institution's Thomas Lovejoy in 1984, these
- innovative deals often involve the cooperation of governments,
- bankers and conservation groups. In a typical debt-for-nature
- swap earlier this year, the World Wildlife Fund, a nonprofit
- organization based in Washington, bought $1 million worth of
- Ecuadoran debt held by Bankers Trust at the discounted price of
- $354,500. The bank was happy to get the troublesome loan off its
- books, while the World Wildlife Fund gained the power to improve
- that country's environment. The fund accomplishes this by
- transferring the loan payments to Fundacion Natura, a
- conservation group in Ecuador. Fundacion Natura, in turn, uses
- the money to protect and maintain national parks and wildlife
- preserves.
- </p>
- <p> However it is accomplished, a greater share of the world's
- capital will have to flow into developing countries. What they
- need, said Senator Albert Gore, is a new Marshall Plan for
- economic development and environmental preservation. But where
- will the money come from? For starters, the U.S. and the Soviet
- Union could reduce military spending in order to boost aid for
- environmental programs. Nobel laureate Murray Gell-Mann, a
- professor of theoretical physics at the California Institute of
- Technology, argued that the superpowers should redefine "global
- security" to include "the issues of population, environment and
- sustainable development." Yet the U.S., the world's largest
- debtor, can no longer supply the bulk of aid to the Third
- World. Nor can the economically strapped Soviet Union provide
- much financial help.
- </p>
- <p> That leaves Japan, now the world's most financially powerful
- country, with a heavy responsibility for taking a leading role
- in bankrolling solutions to the environmental crisis. Japan has
- long shied away from assuming a major place in international
- affairs because of its militaristic adventures of the 1930s and
- '40s, but as Prime Minister Noboru Takeshita has made clear, his
- country realizes its international duty and is willing to
- shoulder it.
- </p>
- <p> Japan's foreign aid appropriations of more than $10 billion
- in 1988 outstripped U.S. outlays, and Tokyo has increased its
- contributions to the World Bank and other environment-conscious
- lending institutions. The Takeshita government is willing to
- give more, but its efforts have ironically been hampered by the
- U.S., which is reluctant to give the Japanese a greater say in
- running these international groups. One solution might be to
- set up a new financial entity, an International Bank for
- Environmental Protection, in which the Japanese could have a
- major responsibility for both funding and management.
- </p>
- <p> America, for its part, is at a turning point. The Reagan
- Administration, with its poor record on environmental issues, is
- coming to a close. President-elect Bush, who turned the
- pollution of Boston Harbor into a successful campaign issue,
- has an opportunity to show that he is serious about saving the
- planet -- even after the election. He sent out an encouraging
- signal last week by naming veteran conservationist William
- Reilly to head the Environmental Protection Agency. Reilly, 48,
- president of the World Wildlife Fund, promised a "new and
- constructive course" on environmental problems. It is none too
- soon.
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-